A Net In Time Schooling
Follow me on Social Media
  • Home
  • A Net In Time Blog
  • Homeschooling Organizations
  • Canadian Content
  • On-line Art Instruction
  • Bible
  • Books
  • Links
    • Puzzle and Page Makers
    • Christian Studies
  • Curriculum sources
  • A Net In Time Store

Review: Tokens of Promise

9/25/2013

 
Picture
I was given this book by Bookcrash in order that I might read it and then give you my thoughts on it.   I was not compensated in any other way.  

This book is an easy read, I got it finished in less than two hours while waiting for my son at his club meeting.   It is one book, divided into two books.  25 chapters in all. 222 pages, followed by notes of the author's research as well as discussion guide. 

I did NOT like this book.   I have a hard time reading booked based in biblical fact that are then fictionalized.  This particular story is based on Genesis 38, the story of Tamar and Judah.    I have a hard time separating the "but you don't know if that was how these folks were, you don't know if they said that, you don't know if ....".   And when I perceive that the truth is being stretched I end up wanting to have nothing to do with it.   I had this too often with this book and it totally turned me off of it.  But I read it through as I promised I would.

Overall the writing style is engaging, you do want to know what happens, you do get a good feel for the characters in the story, you do learn more about the practices of the day and how patriarchal the society was.  There are GOOD things about this book.   There really are.  :)

I'm kinda glad that I persevered as I thoroughly enjoyed going through the author's research notes.   I was also appreciative of the discussion guide, it's good to think more on books and I am happy the author gave that opportunity.

Is that enough to sway my overall opinion of this book? NO.  I do not recommend you read this book.  But if you do, remember this..... it is a work of fiction. 
Disclosure of Material: I received this book free from the publisher through the BookCrash.com book review program, which requires an honest, though not necessarily positive, review. The opinions I have expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s CFR Title 16, Part 255: “Guides Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising.”
Michele Pleasants link
9/26/2013 03:19:52 am

Some books are just like that, huh? I, too, have a hard time fictionalizing the Bible.

Kayla Arrowood link
9/26/2013 03:24:25 am

Thank you for the honest review. I too see where and why you had an issue with it. Some many times people think us reviewers have to write a positive review just because it's what is suppose to happen, Thank you for stepping up for everyone!

annette
9/26/2013 04:19:17 am

Difficult review to write it was.

Lynellen
9/27/2013 04:50:58 am

The bookcrash listing is very clear that this is a Biblical fiction book. If you don't like Biblical fiction to start with, why on earth did you request the book?

annette @ a net in time
9/28/2013 10:21:36 am

Why did I choose to review this? Just because I don't tend to like a genre of books, doesn't mean that there aren't some gems in the midst of them. I've read biblical fiction that I DO like, this just wasn't one of them. I understand taking license in creating a story around a story. I DO NOT understand the changing the actual story and making it into something else. There were biblical UNTRUTHS in this story and I despise that. It is possible to tell the biblical truth and put the story around it, but when you change fundamental truths in the story, then it is no longer biblical, but is just fiction.

Lynellen
10/1/2013 12:32:14 am

Would you please send me an email with the "untruths" that you see?
Thank you.

Teresa Pollard link
10/8/2013 07:01:26 am

I am so sorry that you didn't like Tokens of Promise, but I studied Hebrew for an entire year just so I could study this one story and know EXACTLY what it was saying! So did I stray from the Bible says or from your concept and what you've been taught the Bible says? For example, did you know the name Shelah means "righteous one" and it also means "trickster?"
If he weren't involved, Judah could not have said of Tamar, "she is more righteous than I." These are exactly the same words spoken of King David. I can give you many more examples. The sin of Er in the book is the sin the Talmud (Jewish scriptures) accuse him of. Both ancient and modern scholars accuse Onan of idolatry. Yes, all the trimmings of this novel are entirely fiction-as far as I know there was no iron oven (although this was the very beginning of the Iron Age) and the character of Ruah was constructed from the "someone" who told Judah about Tamar's pregnancy-things like that--but the core story is as true to the Bible as I could get it. I didn't even change the ending which would have been nice to have a "happy ever after" type end. The problem is that most people simply don't understand this story, and because of its sexual nature, it's never been properly taught by the church. They'd rather see it as a "meaningless story of dubious morality" which is what most scholars deem it. But it's not!

annette @ a net in time
10/8/2013 09:35:41 am

my overall thinking is... biblical fiction needs to stay very true to the bible. in this particular story I was bothered too often by the "adding to the story". yes, it was fleshed out... but in that fleshing too often it was like ...hmm... that's not what the bible says, how can this be added, and at the end of it, not my cup of tea. The bits that I was particularly bothered by I would read to my hubby and he (pastoral biblical man) was in agreement that it strayed too far. So that's where I'm at. :)

Candi Pullen
10/9/2013 03:03:03 pm

I confess unashamedly that I know the author well. I co-wrote another book, "Not Guilty" with her thirty years ago that was just published and debuted in February of this year. So now you know how long and how well I know the author's ethic and moral compass, and her passion for research and expertise in writing. I have spent many an evening with her as she worked her way through the research process and decision making of what historical fact of the times should be included based on when it was originally written in the Scriptures. I hold a Bachelor of Theology degree and am also very careful about additions made to Scripture, but find no fault in writing stories based on careful and thorough historical research that includes historical fact not given in the Scriptures. I find it interesting that those unfamiliar with the traditions of certain historical times do not reason that those times helped define the perceptions of the average Bible readers' understanding of the Scriptures of that era. I am actively involved in Bible study on an ongoing basis and I constantly find myself reminding students that they must not apply today's perceptions on those of the past for we live in our own time just as those of history have. When the Bible is read, it should be read in two parts:
1. What was being said at the time of the original writing and...
2. What does it require of me today?
Without authors, like Teresa Pollard, who pursue the painstaking research to ascertain the original understanding of the people living at the time these historical events occurred, as best as one can after so many millenia, how could we understand fully the original intent of the lessons to be learned? God bless the writers who venture forth to weed through years of research before they ever put pen to paper in an effort to maintain historical accuracy and give us glimpses of the times in which these life-giving lessons were first wrought.

Teresa Pollard
10/10/2013 12:34:54 am

Thanks, Candi.

Candi Pullen
10/10/2013 03:45:29 pm

No thanks needed. I simply tried to point your readers to the truth. I only ommitted one thing - in the days of the patriarchs of the faith, life was much less gentile and far more brutal than life today. No one questioned the brutality because it was a requirement of survival. The characters you explored were accurate to their historical era, and our modern views must not be read into their descriptions if we are to fully understand what God is showing us. Instead of debating the representations of the personalities of the past we should be thanking God that man has softened much under the guidance of His love for mankind. Despite their moral frailty our forefathers endured and grew in their basic nature. Thank God that we no longer live according to those ancient survival instincts, but have accepted and allowed God to mature and develop more of His own nature within us through the centuries.


Comments are closed.

    Who Am I?


    Loved by God and family - these things center me

    Writer, Poet, Hiker, Reader - these things make me smile

    Educating, Raising a child, Involved with Critters, Pastor's wife - These things make me grow

    Picture
    Team Member

    Subscribe to our mailing list

    * indicates required
    Blog Roll

    Enter your email address:

    Delivered by FeedBurner

    Subscribe to A Net In Time Schooling - A Net In Time Blog by Email
    My Joy-Filled Life
    Click here to sign up for SchoolhouseTeachers.com
    Visit Annette's profile on Pinterest.
    Picture

    RSS Feed

    Archives

    September 2017
    July 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    February 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    October 2013
    September 2013
    August 2013
    July 2013
    June 2013
    May 2013
    April 2013
    March 2013
    February 2013
    January 2013
    December 2012
    November 2012
    October 2012
    September 2012
    August 2012
    July 2012
    June 2012

    Team Member

    Subscribe to A Net In Time Schooling - A Net In Time Blog

    Picture

    Categories

    All
    Adventus
    Affiliate
    A Journey Through Learning
    Animals
    Ants
    Art
    Art Books
    Atutorsoft Math
    Bible
    Biography
    Birdcage Press
    Blast From The Past
    Blog Hop Or Cruise
    Blog Hop Or Cruise
    Blog The Alphabet
    Blog The Alphabet
    Book Club
    Book Review
    Book Review
    Books For Children
    Books Read Lately
    Book Work Day
    Brainfood Learning
    Canada
    Carnival
    Chess House
    Child Led Learning
    Child Led Learning
    Christianity
    Christianity Cove
    Christmas
    Circle Time
    Cleaning
    Coding For Children
    Community Service
    Computer Work
    Contest
    Conversation Jar
    Cooking Class
    Crickets
    Critical Thinking
    Curriculum
    Day In The Life
    Days Of November
    Devotion
    Devotional Time
    Doctrine
    Earth Science
    Educents
    Email
    Encouragement
    Esl
    Essentials In Writing
    Europe
    Experiment
    Faith Issues
    Family
    Field Trip
    Five Day Blog Hop
    Five Minute Friday
    Five Minute Friday
    Five On The Fifth
    Flyby Promotions
    FoodBank
    Foreign Languages
    For Sale
    Freebies
    French Essentials
    Games
    Gardening
    General Update
    Geography
    Giveaway
    Global Art
    Guest Post
    Hands Of A Child
    Hands On Learning
    Handwriting Without Tears
    Healthy Living
    History
    Holidays
    Homemaking Skills
    Homeschooling
    Homeschooling A Singleton
    Homeschooling Essentials
    Homeschooling Helps
    Homeschool In The Woods
    Homeschool Issues
    Hope
    Human Body
    Hymn
    Insects
    International Student
    Issues In Homeschooling
    I Won It
    Joyce Herzog
    Kick
    K'Nex
    Knights And Castles
    Language Arts
    Language Arts
    Language Study
    Legal Issues
    Lego
    Letters To Pastors Wives
    Mammoth Math
    Math
    Middle School
    Miscellaneous
    Missionaries
    Missions
    Movie
    Museum
    Music
    Nature Study
    Nature-study
    On Line Learning
    Online Learning
    Ontario Science Centre
    Organization
    Outer Space
    Parenting
    People Of Faith
    Philosophy
    Phys Ed
    Pinterest
    Play Dates
    Poetry
    Preschoolers And Peace
    Printable
    Random Five
    Reading
    Reading Kingdom
    Recipe
    Resource
    Review
    Sale
    School Planning
    Science
    Scienceandmathcom
    Series
    Sight Words
    Sponsored Post
    STEM Activities
    Student
    Study Aid
    Sunday School For All Ages
    Supercharged Science
    Taking Time To Think
    Target The Question
    Thinking Out Loud
    Thinking Tuesday
    Time4learning
    Tools
    Tos Review
    Ultimate Bundles
    Vacation
    Vendor Sales
    Website News
    Week In Review
    Westminister Shorter Catechism
    Whats-in-my-browser
    Word Blog Hop
    Wordless Wednesday
    Word Prompt
    Youtube

    RSS Feed

     photo 9c2d3d39-9e5d-4351-b060-d6251ee13eaa_zpseda17cd5.jpg
    Follow on Bloglovin Follow my blog with Bloglovin

    2013 TOS Reviews

    IXL.com
    if you were me
    Chess House
    YWAM
    Seed Sowers
    Time4Learning
    Family Hope Center
    Reading Kingdom
    Bible Study Guide for all ages
    Bird Cage Press
    Christianity Cove
    Math Mammoth
    Joyce Herzog
    Homeschool in the woods
    SuperCharged Science
    Adventus
    LoneStar Learning
    A+tutorsoft Math
    Wet, Dry, Try App
    Schoolhouse Teachers
    French Essentials
    Dogwood Mudhole

    Circle Time
    Gryphon House
    Essentials in Writing
    In the Hands of a Child
    A journey through learning
    Ed Douglas
    Picaboo Yearbooks
    VocabularySpellingCity

    2014 TOS Reviews
    Science4Us.com

    Egglo Entertainment.
    ScienceandMath.com
    Supercharged Science.
    Philippians in 28 weeks.
    CTC math
    The Brinkman Adventures.

    Maestro Classics.
    Logic of English.
    Learning Breakthrough
    Go Science DVD's
    Veritas Press
    Happy Kids Songs
    Wizzy Gizmo: In his image
    UberSmart Software.
    Essential Skills Advantage:

    Other Reviews

    My Beloved ..
    Homemaker's Mentor
    Don't Miss the Boat
    Tokens of Promise
    Biff and Becka's ....
    A Child's Geography
    Homeless at Harvard
    30 Days of Bible Study...
    Topaz and the Evil Wizard
    Alone yet not alone
    Lead me Home
    I am Second
    Can't wait Willow
    Hey God....
    This is Our Time
    What I wish I knew at 18
    Classical Composers
    Seeking Christmas.
    Raising boys by design.
    The Ruby Ring.
    Knowing God By name.
    The Jesus Bible, NIV. 
    One Realm Beyond.
Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.